Jun 30, 2020
Lebanese judge bans media from talking to U.S. ambassador after Hezbollah leaders criticism
This news has been received from: newsbrig.com
All trademarks, copyrights, videos, photos and logos are owned by respective news sources. News stories, videos and live streams are from trusted sources.
BEIRUT — The U.S. ambassador to Lebanon has vowed she won’t be silenced despite a court order banning media outlets from talking to her — a ruling that was slammed by some within the Lebanese government — after she criticized the country’s most powerful party amid an escalating financial crisis.
A judge passed an order to stop media outlets from speaking to Dorothy Shea or reporting her comments for a year or face a $200,000 fine and a broadcasting ban if adopted by the country’s Information Ministry, after she publicly criticized Hezbollah, the Iran-backed political party and militant group that controls the country’s government.
Saturday’s ruling by Judge Mohammed Mazeh, who is based in the southern Hezbollah stronghold of Tyre, came after Shea accused Hezbollah of destabilizing an economic recovery in Lebanon and siphoning billions of dollars from the government.
Shea’s comments in a TV interview on the Saudi state-owned broadcaster Al-Hadath came after Hezbollah leader Hassan Nasrallah claimed in a speech June 16 that Lebanon’s crippling dollar shortage was the result of a U.S conspiracy. He added that the United States was trying to starve Lebanon and said “we will kill them” before that could happen.Supporters of the Lebanese Shiite movements Hezbollah and Amal lift flags and placards as they protest a statement made by the US ambassador criticising the group, in Beirut on Sunday.Anwar Amro / AFP – Getty Images
Shea discussed the potential for further sanctions targeting the group and said Nasrallah’s speech was “riddled with classic deflections — blaming everything on the United States when we’re Lebanon’s biggest donor.”
But Lebanon’s Information Ministry denied that freedom of speech was being curtailed.
Let our news meet your inbox. The news and stories that matters, delivered weekday mornings.
“No one has the right to ban media from carrying news or limit its media freedom,” Information Minister Manal Abdel-Samad said shortly after the announcement.
Several local television channels ignored the ruling and aired interviews with Shea on Sunday in which she doubled down in her criticism.
“I think it is a distraction. I wish people would spend their time and attention trying to solve the problems facing the country,” she told the Lebanese news station MTV. “The U.S Embassy will not be silenced.”
Lebanon is in the midst of its biggest economic crash in modern history with the local currency, which has been pegged to the dollar for decades, losing 80 percent of its value since October. The prospect of widespread hunger is looming over much of the country as wages plummet, unemployment soars and prices skyrocket.
The country has been locked in crisis talks with the International Monetary Fund since May, but on Monday a second high-level Lebanese official resigned from the national negotiating team, with no agreement in sight.
Hezbollah, the most powerful Iran-backed group in the region, is designated as a terrorist organization by the U.S., the United Kingdom and Germany, but holds political office in Lebanon.
The group is highly influential in the region and plays a key role in political and military matters. It fought alongside Syrian President Bashar al-Assad in the Syrian war and fought a four-week war with neighboring Israel in 2006, a conflict that has sporadically flared up since.U.S. Ambassador to Lebanon Dorothy Shea speaks during a news conference after meeting with Lebanon’s Foreign Minister Nassif Hitti at the Ministry of Foreign Affairs in Beirut on Monday.Mohamed Azakir / Reuters
Washington is, however, the largest donor to the Lebanese army, leading to a complex and delicately balanced relationship.
The ruling is the most prominent in a recent string of cases of people speaking out against Hezbollah and the government. The judge said the ambassador’s words “offended many Lebanese,” pitted them against each other and “constitutes pouring oil on the fire of [sectarian] strife.”
The backlash against the ruling was swift and the ambassador was summoned to meet Lebanese Foreign Minister Nassif Hitti on Monday, while Mazeh offered to resign by Tuesday.
“We turned the page on this unfortunate distraction so we can all focus on the real crisis at hand, which is the deteriorating economic situation in Lebanon,” Shea said following the meeting.
Hezbollah-affiliated lawyers demonstrated outside Beirut’s Justice Palace on Monday in solidarity with Mazeh’s gag order.
Reuters contributed to this report
News Source: newsbrig.com
De Blasio: Comparing Protests to Religious Services Apples and Oranges
On Wednesday’s broadcast of CNN’s “New Day,” New York City Mayor Bill de Blasio (D) defended treating religious services differently from protests despite a court ruling that doing so was wrong by stating that “The protests were an entirely different reality,” and that comparing the protests to religious services is “really apples and oranges.”
De Blasio said, “We worked with the religious leadership of this city for months. Cardinal Dolan in the Catholic Church, and so many other religious leaders, who were in full agreement that it was not time to bring back religious services because of the danger it would cause to their congregants. The protests were an entirely different reality, a national phenomenon, that was not something that the government could just say, go away. It’s something that really came from the grassroots. And obviously, it had a profound meaning, and we’re all acting on the meaning of those protests. But it’s really apples and oranges. Our religious leaders were the first to say it was not time to bring back services. Now, we’re doing it carefully, smartly. So, I think that decision profoundly misses what the very religious institutions themselves were saying.”
Follow Ian Hanchett on Twitter @IanHanchett